- Nike Womens Blazer Mid Vintage Suede High Top Fashion Sneakers
- Gentle Souls Womens Troy Closed Toe Mid-Calf Fashion Boots
- Replay Mens Sneakers GMZ97 .003.C0001S
- Men's Driving shoes Casual shoes Outdoor Leather Flat shoes Comfortable Loafers Peas shoes
- ZHRUI Man Sneakers Casual shoes Spring Autumn Platform Walking Outdoor Footwear Male (color Green, Size 5.5=39 EU)
- Men’s Genuine Leather Made in Brazil Union Street Driver Marc Joseph NY Fashion shoes
- TRAVEL FOX Men's Orlando Oily Leather Moccasin Toe Braided Lace Loafer
- Smoked Pearl Ariat Women's Fernlee Rain Boot
- JQSM Crossbody Leather Woman Handbag Leather Black Tote Bag Floral Embossed Handbag Ladies Shoulder Bag
- Goodtrade8 Boots Vintage Women Flat Round Toe Canvas shoes Comfortable Soles Zipper Single shoes
- AmoonyFashion Womens Closed Round Toe Low Heels Imitated Suede Fluff Solid Boots with Chunky Heels, bluee, 7.5 B(M) US
- Ellie shoes Women's 601 Coco Platform Sandal
- WeiPoot Women's Square Closed Toe Pull On Pu Solid Kitten Heels Pumps-shoes
- U.S. Polo Assn. Womens Isabel-hj Fashion Sneaker
- Jerusalem Sandals Womens Tamar Slide Sandal
- HuaHua-Store Vintage Country Style Square Toe Slip On Mules Pretty Girls Large Size Slippers Straw shoes
I’m a big fan of the magical school trope. J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter series was one of those life-defining books from high school through the end of college, and Lev Grossman’s The Magicians books came right in after as I was starting my career as a college administrator and writer. Sarah Gailey’s debut novel Magic for Liars is like a third part of that transition, and I blew through the book in just about a day.
The story introduces us to Ivy Gamble, a woman who works as a private investigator, and who has a bit of a secret: her estranged twin sister is a brilliant magician. She’s hired by the headmaster of the Osthorne Academy of Young Mages in California, where her sister works. The two haven’t spoken in years, and when a teacher at the school is found dead in the library, they’re unexpectedly reunited.
Gailey is the author of the American Hippo novellas, and while I loved the concept, I felt that they were a bit weak, character-wise (one of the downsides to Tor.com’s novella line: sometimes, a story is too slimmed down, and could have been a bit longer.) That isn’t a problem here. Gailey brilliantly sets up these two sisters, and Ivy is a phenomenal, bitter character who is pretty much burned out on everything, stemming back to some deep-seated family history that drove her and her sister apart.
This book succeeds in two ways. First, it’s a fantastic mystery, and Gamble, an outsider to this magical community, is the perfect person to solve it, because she can approach it from that unknowledgeable angle, but who knows how perfectly messed up people are, and what sorts of bad decisions they can make. Secondly, it’s a great magical school entry. Hogwarts is delightfully twee, Brakebills College for Magical Pedagogy is realistically cynical, and the Osthorne Academy of Young Mages is… a typical high school. There’s plenty of details that show off that kids — even magical kids, will be immature, do stupid things, are egotistical, and crave attention.
What really makes this book stand out is that it revolves around a couple of things that fantasy (and science fiction, for that matter), typically ignores: wOmEnS IsSuEs. I won’t spoil how this plays out, but it’s a mystery that comes down to teenage and family drama in ways that feels utterly realistic, and I’m guessing entirely relevant and relatable to any woman who picks up this book. Gailey also keeps the mystery entirely fresh throughout the entire read, throwing me off in a couple of places, and nailing the book with a fantastic (and frustratingly ambiguous) ending. She tells me that she’s not planning on a followup, which is also refreshing? There needs to be more standalone novels, although I would dearly love to see more of this particular world.